Topchubashov Center
Expert opinion 2 min read

Ukraine: can negotiations be fruitful right now?

Ukraine: can negotiations be fruitful right now?
Murad Muradov Co-founder, Deputy Director Published

Listen to this article Read by an AI voice

After the latest announcements from the Ukrainian side that "the parties to negotiations have agreed on almost all the issues except for Crimea" or information that the Putin-Zelensky meeting "is not impossible", some have started to believe that some form of peace or ceasefire is around. Personally, I believe it is not true, and that's why: Whatever they say, the conditions on the table now would be humiliating for Russia as they would in substance mean more or less a return to the situation of 23.02.2022, and this time with security guarantees for Ukraine. It's not a secret that Zelensky had been in principle ready to discuss the neutral status of Ukraine in January-February, it was the Russian side that ignored his invitations for genuine talks. Anyway, the example of Sweden or Finland demonstrated that it is possible to be an EU member with strong armed forces while remaining neutral. So, for Putin, after the draconian sanctions, thousands of lives lost and destroyed international reputation, it will be almost impossible to sell this not even as a victory, but at least as an honorary draw. Hence Kadyrov's open disagreement with Medinsky and calls "to go until the end" are unsurprising, and there is strong anecdotal evidence that Putin remains strongly opposed to concluding a peace deal now. The situation may change only in three cases. Either one side should suffer a very grave defeat (akin to the one Azerbaijan had in the winter of 1993-94), which is unlikely given Russia's advantage in numbers and WMDs on one hand and growing Western support to Ukraine on the other; the "party of peace" within Russian elites should be able to neutralize Putin and his close circle hellbent on waging this war and put the blame for all this catastrophe on them, or major political perturbations in Russia bring to power a completely new group unconnected to the incumbent one and hence free from all its debts and burdens. But again, all these scenarios seem to be very unlikely as of now. And I'm sure that the major Western supporters of Ukraine understand that to agree on Putin's survival, let alone somehow forgo what's happening, is a recipe for a delayed death. Thus, Zelensky's statement that Ukraine ultimately relies on her armed forces, is completely rational and understandable.

Related work

Expert opinion

US foreign policy before midterm election

As the US midterm election is approaching, the correlation between President Trump’s statements and actual US policies, gets more and more uncertain. And while his occasional eccentricities on Twitter or during rallies with supporters, have become part of a po...

Murad Muradov, 27 October 2026

Expert opinion

Connecting Central Asia and the South Caucasus

On November 15, Azerbaijan formally joined the Central Asian Consultative Meetings, expanding what was known as the Central Asian Five (C5) into a Central Asian Six (C6). Many in Central Asia find it surprising. But when viewed through the lens of recent geopo...

Gulkhanim Mammadova, 1 December 2025

Expert opinion

Azerbaijan joins the C5: implications for Eurasian regional architecture

When the long-standing C5 format of Central Asian cooperation formally expanded into a C6 on 15 November in Tashkent, Azerbaijan’s accession was framed as a natural extension of historical and linguistic affinities. Yet behind the rhetoric lies a structural tr...

Gulkhanim Mammadova, 21 November 2025

Expert opinion

Kazakhstan joins the Abraham Accords: Pragmatism or Symbolism?

Kazakhstan’s accession to the Abraham Accords—anticipated in some political circles—may still raise eyebrows. Unlike the original signatories, who were establishing relations with Israel from scratch, Kazakhstan has long maintained cordial ties with the Jewish...

Rusif Huseynov, 9 November 2025

Expert opinion

13 June attack: quick comments

In the most extensive attack on Iran since the country’s 1980-88 war with Iraq, Israeli forces have launched multiple waves of nationwide bombings. The attack is ongoing and believed to be the opening shots of a wider campaign to degrade Iran’s military comman...

Murad Muradov, 13 June 2025

Expert opinion

Historic First in Tbilisi: Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia trilateral talks

On April 17, Tbilisi hosted the first-ever formal trilateral meeting between the foreign ministries of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. According to official statements, the primary aim of the meeting was to create a platform for open dialogue and to explore p...

Gulkhanim Mammadova, 17 April 2025

Expert opinion

Munich speech, 18 years later

The Munich speech of the U.S. Vice President J. D. Vance will definitely enter the textbooks of the future as one of the harbingers of a new historic period. This speech has been arguably more shocking than Vladimir Putin’s diatribe he made on the same stage 1...

Murad Muradov, 19 February 2025